Law Offices of Edward J. Singer APLC

MTA BUS DRIVER STABBED: INJURED WORKERS IN THE NEWS #85

Posted on May 28, 2023 by Edward Singer

An Irate Passenger stabbed a MTA Bus Driver’s left hand. It was reported that the two had gotten into an argument. As a result of the injury, the driver was taken to the hospital and was reportedly in stable condition. Nypost.com

This article will discuss how this matter will be assessed as a work injury and how the permanent disability will be assessed.

If The Assault Was Brought On By A Worker-Customer Argument, Would The Stabbing Be Considered Work-Related?

Most likely yes. If the argument was only verbal, then the matter would remain as a work-related injury and the MTA Bus Driver would receive workers’ compensation benefits. Had there been an argument and the MTA Bus Driver initiated the physical violence upon the Passenger, then the “initial physical aggressor” rule which bars compensation would have to be addressed. If the Driver was found to be the “initial physical aggressor”, then benefits would be barred. This factual determination is the purview of Workers’ Compensation Judge. As such, it would be likely that a Trial with testimony would occur.

What Types Of Injuries Occurred In This Incident?

Given this fact pattern, a stabbing injury is likely to cause an orthopedic hand injury, a possible transmission of a blood borne illness, and perhaps a psychiatric injury.

How Does One Assess A Hand Impairment Injury?

In Cailfornia, Permanent Disability Percentage is calculated by using the AMA Guides for the evaluation of permanent impairment. According to the AMA, the ”AMA Guides provide a reliable, repeatable measurement framework for permanent impairment in patients who have suffered an injury or illness resulting in long-term loss of a body part or reduction of body function.” With respect to a Hand Impairment, loss of range of motion and possibly grip loss will be assessed. Likewise, since it was a stabbing injury, ia skin disorder or a nerve disorder may also be evaluated concerning impairment.

What if I Need Advice?

If you would like a free consultation regarding workers’ compensation, please contact the Law Offices of Edward J. Singer, a Professional Law Corporation. We have been helping people in Central and Southern California deal with their workers’ compensation cases for 30 years. Contact us today for more information.

BUS DRIVER STRESSED AND SPRAYED UPON: INJURED WORKERS IN THE NEWS #81

Posted on April 17, 2023 by Edward Singer

Tormented by students, a School Bus Driver went viral tirade when she quit her job. The Asthmatic Bus Driver reportedly suffered attacks after students repeatedly sprayed perfume on her. Upon the second spraying. she became irate. She said that was done with “this sh@$”, and left her job of two years. dailymail.com

This article will discuss whether the incidents could constitute a work injury.

Did These Instances Constitute Work Injuries?

In California Workers’ Compensation Law, the aggravation or acceleration of an underlying medical condition can be considered as a work-related injury. Given the fact pattern, if there was a medical opinion that the Bus Driver’s condition asthma condition was somehow aggravated or accelerated then there would be a respiratory work injury. If so, she would be entitled to claim workers’ compensation benefits. These benefits include monetary compensation and medical treatment.

Even if there was no asthma injury, the stressful nature of the incident could constitute a work injury. A stress or psychiatric injury may be indicated. Again, such a claim would also require a medical professional rendering an opinion that there was an injury. The bottom line is that, regardless of how horrible the facts, they are not a substitute for medical reporting.

In sum, it is possible that both asthma and psyche injuries occurred. In that instance, it can be asserted that the Bus Driver is claiming two injured body parts.

If There Was No Asthma Injury, Can There Still Be A Psyche Injury?

Yes. In California, even if there was no asthma injury, a psychiatric claim could still be viable. In that instance, the asthma attacks could have been a mere exacerbation the Bus Driver’s pre-existing condition. The perfume may not have caused any injury but rather a momentary flare up. Both of these episodes could have caused emotional upset. If the Bus Driver could prove that the predominant cause of an emotional condition was caused by the bullying and the perfume spraying, she could pursue a psyche work injury. Again, the opinion on causation and on medical condition injured requires the opinion of a mental health professional such as a psychiatrist or psychologist.

What if I Need Advice?

LAX Shuttle Crash With Plane: Injured Workers in the News, #76

Posted on February 15, 2023 by Edward Singer

A LAX Shuttlebus collided with a taxiing Airplane. It was reported that the plane struck the bus. The news account indicated that the cause of the injury was unknown.

As a result of the accident, both the Tug Driver and the Bus Driver may have both been injured and required hospitalization. nypost.com

This article will discuss the nature of fault with respect to an accident and its impact on a workers’ compensation claim.

Even if fault has not been established, can these Injured Workers pursue workers’ compensation claims?

Yes. Workers’ compensation is a “no fault” system. Thus, even if either the tug operator or the bus driver were negligent, both employees can pursue claims with their employer. Labor Code Section 3600(a) provides for compensation without regard to negligence. Absent any exception to the rule, it would appear that both workers have valid work injury claims.

If negligence was established against one of the drivers, can they still pursue a workers’ compensation claim?

Yes. An Injured Worker who got hurt as a result of their own negligence, in general, can pursue a claim. Labor Code Section 3600(a) provides for compensation without regard to negligence. Absent any exception to the rule, it would appear that both workers have valid work injury claims.

What if I Need Advice?

A BUSLOAD OF BUS DRIVERS INJURED WHEN THE WHEELS ON THE BUS DIDN’T GO ROUND N’ ROUND: INJURED WORKERS IN THE NEWS #49

Posted on July 25, 2022 by Edward Singer

A bus load of Bus Drivers were injured when a bus driven by a Bus Driver flipped and crashed. Dailymail.com

It is reported that “the bus had been carrying 37 adults – 36 passengers and the driver – police said. Police had said those on board were employees of the same company, but did not specify the origination. All 36 passengers were treated for injuries at the scene, police said Thursday, with three needing to be hospitalized.” Dailymail.com

This article will address of an issue that results from an industrial accident involving multiple workers.

Is There A Personal Injury Claim that Can Be Filed Against the Bus Driver?

No. It is reported that all of the passengers worked for the same company. Thus, workers’ compensation is the appropriate venue.

Since Everyone Was in the Same Accident, Will They All Receive the Same Recovery?

No. The fact that two individuals are in the same accident does not mean that they will receive the same recovery.

There are many factors that will create different results for disability awards.

Impairments: The body parts injured and the nature and extent of the injuries will determine the disability percentage.

Apportionment: Applicants with pre-existing disabilities or prior work injury awards may have their injuries reduced based upon these factors.

Age: Ratings are determined based upon age. Younger Employers get less value that older workers. This is based upon a table in the SCHEDULE FOR RATING PERMANENT DISABILITIES

Occupation: Ratings are determined by Occupational Group. In this instance, since all of the workers are bus drivers, they will all be assigned a bus driver group number. Had there been other types of workers in the bus, different group numbers would be assigned. Those group number could impact a rating percentage to go up, down or remain the same.

What if I Need Advice?